收藏|审稿人意见修回信件模板|论文投稿

1

审稿人意见修回,按字面理解就是针对审稿人对论文提出的要求进行“修改”并“回复意见”,当审稿人对投递的论文提出修改意见后,论文作者需要对自己的论文进行审查及修改并对审稿人进行回复。

审稿人提出的意见可能有:小修后接受,大修后接受以及修改后重投。但是依然有着”反复修改“和”修改后拒收“的可能性。

所以,在收到审稿人意见后,认真地进行论文修改是很重要的,如果对审稿人意见有不太赞同的地方,我们也可以通过诚意的信件来提出我们的见解。

2

未收到审稿人意见/询问审稿人意见:

Dear Dr. Meng,

I am very pleased to receive your letter.  However,I am confused and would like an explanation regarding the status of my paper.

I submitted my paper entitled 'XXX' on 20th May. The status of my paper recorded on the website is 'Editorial decision making';does this mean that my paper's reviewing has been completed?If so, I have not received any reviewers' comments.

If my paper's reviewing has been completed, and you need us to revise our paper and write a reply letter in response to the reviewers' comments, could you please send the reviewers' comments to us?

If my paper has not been sent out for reviewing, could you please help to send it out for reviewing as soon as possible? We have just added an Ethics Statement in our paper, and which has been stated in the cover letter.

I apologize for any confusion, and I will be most grateful if you could help to inform us of our paper's status..

Thank you very much for your consideration, and I look forward to hearing from you soon.

With kind regards,

Sincerely yours,

XXX

3

针对审稿人意见逐条回复:

Dear Editor,

Thank you for your kind letter of '……' on May **, 2019. We revised the manuscript in accordance with the reviewers' comments, and carefully proof-read the manuscript to minimize typographical, grammatical, and bibliographical errors.

Here below is our description on revision according to the reviewers' comments.

Part A (Reviewer 1)

1.The reviewer's comment:……

The authors' Answer:……

2.The review's comment:……

The authors' Answer:……

...

Part B (Reviewer 2)

1.The reviewer's comment:……

The authors' Answer:……

2.The review's comment:……

The authors' Answer:……

...

……

Many grammatical or typographical errors have been revised.

All the lines and pages indicated above are in the revised manuscript.

Thank you and all the reviewers for the kind advice.

Sincerely yours,

***

※注意:

1.针对有异议的审稿人意见可引用有关文献等进行委婉说明。

2.针对不同审稿人意见一定要逐条回复

4

因为某些强制性原因无法及时提交修回信件:

Urgent:  Regarding resubmission of XXX-2019-1118

Dear XXX,

Thank you very much for your kind reminder and advice.

We apologize for not re-submitting  this manuscript before the deadline. Please excuse us for the inconvenience we have caused. As the corresponding author, ……(无法及时回复的原因), so I could not receive your decision letter on time. We have revised the paper according to the reviewers' comments today and hope you can accept our apology and agree to review the revised version of our manuscript. Could you please give us a chance to submit our revision online?Thank you!

I look forward to your reply!

On behalf of the conrresonding authror:XXX

来源:巴典科研

本文来源:本公号标明转载文章的出处,版权归原作者所有,转载仅作分享之用。如有侵权,请与我们联系,将于24小时内删除。

(0)

相关推荐

  • 自己投的稿,含着泪也要读完这些奇葩毒舌的审稿意见

    审稿人什么的,简直太讨厌了!他们跟你的沟通要么热情诚恳,要么郑重其事,但他们与期刊编辑之间的沟通就随意多了.你知道审稿人在背着你说你的哪些坏话吗?请看-- 中英对照版 1.The writing an ...

  • 如何评审一篇论文?(How to review a paper?)

    前言 本文旨在讲述:如何评审一篇论文? How to review a paper? [1] Peer Review at Science Publications. http://www.scien ...

  • APL投稿经验

    整个花了三个月的时间,投的是超表面方向的,当时选择的是介质介电方向.送审的副主编是国立台湾大学的林敏聪,副主编在一审的时候送审了三个审稿人都是拒绝审稿(当时这个第一个版本写得太乱了,这个拒绝审稿有看不 ...

  • 投稿必备:如何写好response letter?(内附写作模板)

    Response letter的主要目的是回复你采纳了审稿人哪些有助于提高论文质量的意见,并表明做出了哪些修改.所以这意味着不必同意审稿人所有建议的更改,但是你需要知道如何以适当的方式说明为什么拒绝修 ...

  • 速收藏 !回复审稿人意见时常用的英文套话

    拿到审稿意见时... 下面收集了一些回复审稿人意见时常用的套话,赶紧收藏!(搬运工具人.gif) 一些回复的模板 模板1 Dear prof. XX and dear reviewers Re: Ma ...

  • “好论文都是改出来的”,降重、润色、审稿人意见如何修改?

    近日,关于<经历上百次修改,这所985高校诞生首篇Science!发一篇顶刊有多难?>的推文登上了各大公众号的头版头条.故事主要讲述了上海交通大学颜德岳教授和他的博士生在实验室实现了分子的 ...

  • 审稿人意见不一致怎么办?该听谁的?这些策略你需要知道→

    " "同行评议的墨菲定律"告诉我们, 如果一个审稿人赞扬你的手稿, 第二个审稿人则会让你修改它.                             --Adam R ...

  • 如何回复审稿人意见?

    一般审稿过程 正确.有效的回复审稿人的意见对于手稿发表是非常重要的.大多审稿意见都是为了让作者更好的提高论文质量,达到出版的水平. 关于如何回复审稿人意见,埃米编辑(中国)高级学术顾问中科院大连化学物 ...

  • sci论文在多久之内回复审稿人意见

    sci论文在多久之内回复审稿人意见?这个时间一般是有要求的,具体的时间因刊物要求不同而不同,一般在审稿人给作者的审稿建议和修改意见中有详细说明,因此,作者收到审稿建议后,不单单要关注审稿人的审稿意见, ...

  • sci论文在多长时间捏回复审稿人意见

    投稿后的sci论文,经过审核后,会有拒稿.修改和录用三种结果.收到"修改"回复的作者,一般要在规定时间内修改并回复审稿人意见.那么,sci论文在多长时间捏回复审稿人意见? 在拒稿. ...

  • 修稿时答复审稿人具体意见的三段结构及推荐文献

    几乎所有的期刊都要求作者在上传修改稿时,同时上传一个针对每位审稿人审稿意见的一封答复函.按要求书写答复函,一方面可以帮助更好地修改论文,另一方面可以建立与审稿人之间的良好关系,让审稿人在接下来的审稿中 ...

  • 论文修回后是否再次回到审稿人手中?取决于你的回复

    我们的论文送出去外审了,然后我们收到的结果可能是拒稿,也可能是小修,也可能是大修,也可能是直接接收.如果我们的论文是小修或者大修,那么我们就需要修改,然后再提交.很多人就会担心:论文修回后是否再次回到 ...

  • 建议收藏:让SCI审稿人挑不出毛病的回复

    众所周知,一篇SCI大概要经过3个阶段,即做实验.写作成稿和投稿修稿.每一个阶段都非常考验人,整个过程下来几乎能榨干你的最后一滴脑汁. 如果你已经度过前2个阶段,并已投出manuscript(手稿), ...